So, William F. Buckley Jr. died recently. While it is likely in poor taste to make remarks so soon, the willingness of others to engage in hyperbole has set off my bullshit-o-meter and I felt the need to weigh in. Some of you may remember that a while back I linked to the videos on YouTube of Buckley and Noam Chomsky debating foreign relations, concluding that Buckley was an imperialist fascist who didn’t know a reasonable argument from his asshole. While this is perhaps a bit of an overstatement, re-watching the videos (which I have subsequently done a number of times) never seems to temper this prior opinion. There was an occasion where he was supposed to be on the Daily Show a short while ago, but it never materialized. I was salivating over the anticipated exchange.
With all due respect for the deceased, William F. Buckley was many things, and the majority of those things I did not like. He is credited with the conservative movement in America, appeared to be something of a fan of imperialism, and an master of the now popular method of bullshitting your way through a debate by avoiding substantive challenges and relying on tactless innuendo and conjecture.
Yet, based on the responses to news of his death, you would think he were the Messiah redux. John McCain apparently said, “With Bill’s passing, freedom has lost one of its greatest defenders … an American giant who shall be missed.” President Bush said, “
Now, if you want to have heroes of your political ideology, fine. If you want to laud their contributions to your ideology, go ahead. What I do not find reasonable is equivocating contributions to the conservative movement with contributions to
I’m sure plenty of red-blooded and red-faced conservatives would find this offensive, but then again I found almost everything Buckley ever said to be offensive to decent, reasonable minded people. He was divisive in a way that this country may never recover from, and to heap praises upon him as a “giant” and grant him the torch of the founding fathers seems to me completely inane. He was a showman and a trumpeter for a band that marches against anything that isn’t playing baseball while fucking an apple pie and humming the star spangled banner (and probably praying while doing so). He was a giant for American conservatism, no doubt, but not for Americans and not for American ideals. I will not canonize Michael Moore upon his death, just like I would ask conservatives not to canonize Buckley, but it is far too late for that. Fie on me for not immediately denouncing socialism because it isn’t democracy, or smiling smugly when I know I’ve been bested argumentatively. His spirit does not live on inside of me.
-Casimir


