It is no secret that I am not a fan of Catholicism, or really any religion in general. To be honest, Catholic mass is more responsible for my conversion to atheism than really any other single factor (full disclosure, I was never Catholic). I have been as appalled by the sex abuse scandals as anyone, I am just less surprised than most. After all, what good can possibly come of telling someone to spend their entire life ignoring a biological urge and rejecting the possibility of sharing your existence with a family of your own?
What has motivated me to finally say something on the subject is the recent public relations counteroffensive by the Vatican and its representatives to manipulate the emotions of its followers around the most significant religious holiday in Christianity. Yes, Rome is in full spin mode, and it couldn’t possibly be any more ridiculous than one of the richest, most prolific, most high profile and powerful sects of a religion playing the victim card. You have got to be fucking kidding me.
“World’s highest profile trannys.”
Now, of course the Vatican is not going to admit outright fault in the abuse allegations and certainly they will have to defend “God’s voice” and his “infallible” nature, even if Benedict was directly linked to many of the global cases of abuse and cover-up during his tenure as the Prefect of the Congregation for the Doctrine of the Faith. Yet, I do not see the logic in the pontiff’s personal preacher Rev. Raniero Cantalamessa arguing during a Good Friday homily that the attacks on the pope are similar to the anti-Semitism that led to the Holocaust.
Religions are often shameless in playing this victim card, but to compare a multi-national scandal of abuse towards children and the subsequent criticism that follows as comparable to Hitler stoking the flames of racism to clear the way for ethnic cleansing is outright irresponsible and dishonorable. Although, if anyone were able to see parallels, I suppose it might be a former Hitler youth and German infantryman. Yeah, let’s not forget that people are shocked that Benedict may have acted unscrupulously in the past when he was once considered the future of the Aryan race and was complicit in the genocide around him.
The Vatican distanced themselves from the comments of that reverend as they acknowledged the comments were not the most prudent. However, the Vatican newspaper L’Osservatore Romano on Saturday denounced what it called the “vile defamation campaign” against the pontiff. How precisely is it defamation to make true statements about a person and the institution of which he is the head? Perhaps there would be no defamation campaign if the pope and the Catholic church had nothing for which they could be held responsible.
“How is his fashion sense not a sin?”
Finally, at Easter Mass today Cardinal Angelo Sodano, dean of the College of Cardinals defended the Pope as “unfailing” and denounced the “petty gossip” about his involvement and responsibility with the sexual abuse scandals. For information on the countries involved in Catholic sex abuse scandals, see this link. Suffice it to say, the staggering amount of accusations hardly seem so frivolous as to be lumped together with gossip. Trivializing the legitimacy of the pain of so many is, in my humble opinion, not the way for the Catholic church to care for the faithful and prove to the rest of the world that they can repent for their infallibility.
This callous attempt at rebuffing allegations seems to me like a petty parry of a serious issue in favor of making it about their own hurts. Yet, I am not sympathetic to the pontiff and his damaged credibility, or whether or not his emotions are suffering because so many have stepped forward to decry the abuse of children. I do not feel that the church as a whole is the victim of discrimination and slander akin to anti-Semitism circa 1940. If there were a right way to handle the uprising of abuse victims against an institution that accounted for abusive priests while marginalizing the victims in order to shield their own image, this is not it.
–Casimir